The genius of Grainger's re-creation of Gershwin is not only
that it makes
pianistic what was essentially orchestral and vocal, but also that it gives in under 25
minutes a very satisfying emotional traversal of the opera. In addition to material from
the introduction and the finale, the Fantasy includes settings, imaginatively
knit together, of 9 songs, perhaps the opera's most familiar 'hits', in Grainger's, not
Gershwin's, order: My Man's Gone Now; It Ain't Necessarily So; Clara, Don't You Be
Down-hearted; Strawberry Call; Summertime; Oh, I Can't Sit Down; Bess, You Is My Woman,
Now; Oh, I Got Plenty O'Nuttin; and Oh, Lawd, I'm On My Way. The opening and closing
sections of the Fantasy parallel the opening and closing of the opera. Serena's passionate
aria, My Man's Gone Now, the Fantasy's first song, represents a kind of emotional
summing-up of the action that preceded it in scene I of the opera, the crap game and the
murder. Sportin' Life mocks the fundamentalist beliefs of Catfish Row's Christians in
It
Ain't Necessarily So, followed immediately in the Fantasy by the chorus's consoling advice
to Clara, Clara, Don't You Be Down-hearted. Normalcy and joy in community life find
expression in The Strawberry Call, Summertime, Clara's lullaby to her sleeping child in
the opening scene of the opera, and Oh, I Can't Sit Down, the exuberant chorus sung on
the way to the Kittiwah picnic. Porgy's transformation by Bess' love is expressed in one
of opera's greatest love duets, Bess, You Is My Woman Now, and his renewed
sense of self, in the jaunty Oh, I Got Plenty O'Nuttin. The opera's and the
Fantasy's final
song, Porgy's quasi spiritual, Oh, Lawd, I'm On My Way, underlines our hero's resolve to
find Bess in what has by now become Gershwin's epic tragedy of love and loss.
|